Subsections
|
``The racing stand still'' from the German magazin ``der Spiegel''.
|
- Increasing individual mobility.
- Urban sprawl.
- Globalisation of markets.
- Decentralization, out-sourcing.
- Safety, health and well-being.
- High quality mobility not available to everybody.
- Isolation.
|
The graph shows the total person km per year in the European union
from 1970 to
1996 [1,2].
Reasons for Capacity problems:
- Mobility doubled from 17.2km/year per person in 1970 to
34.7km/year per person in 1996. Also the quality of mobility
improved considerably as cars became affordable for most families:
24h availability, individual door-to-door service.
- annual growth =4.7% until 1989 and =5.5%. This may be due
to the opening and economical activities of the east European
countries.
- Specialization in production processes requires new
infrastructures: the trends of decentralization and out-sourcing
increase the importance of transport in industrial production. On
the other hand, transport and logistics represent in average
approximately 30% of the total costs of a product. Therefore, new
transport concepts are required that are flexible and that can be
better integrated into production processes.
- Pre industrial cities where mono centered or developed along
corridors (usually main roads or railway lines). Then cities grew
rapidly and became poly-centered. As private cars became largely
available, the places to live, to work, to purchase goods and to do
other activities became separated. The consequence is an enormous
increase in transport demand for which present, corridor oriented
public transport is no more suitable. It appears that the car has
increasingly problems to cope with the required amount of traffic as
road building is limited and provocates resistance of local
inhabitants. Public mass transit like trains, metros or busses work
only efficient in the above mentioned corridor-oriented city
structures. In todays poly centred cities, they can only be operated
with a large amount of subsidizes.
Social problems:
- road traffic is not only a safety issue, it scares also
non-users and stresses users, resulting in a decrease of life
quality.
- the danger on the streets prevents many parents from letting
their children play outside with their friends.
- children, elderly persons and handicapped have only limited
access to cars (they often rely on other persons who drive). In
Germany, approximately 35% of the population is younger than 18 or older
than 65 years, with an increasing trend.
- not having access to individual transport means for many persons
living in isolation. Furthermore it is more difficult to carry goods
from more remote, but cheaper shopping centers.
- to drive a car is more and more often a requirement for an
employment. However a part of those who are seeking for a job do not
have the financial resources to by and maintain a car, in particular
liquids.
- pollution
- global warming
- noise
- waste
- land-use
- intersection of wildlife
|
|
Here the accumulated amount of CO2 is shown with data from
[3]. For the global warming
the total amount of CO2 in the air is decisive and not the
production per year. However, even the CO2 production per year is
expected to increase.
The background image is an infra-red photography of the earth, which
has been used to indicate an increase of the average earth
temperature.
|
- costs of slow and unreliable transport.
- medical costs.
- insurance.
- inefficient use of transport infrastructure and vehicles.
- restoration of buildings.
Costs that are difficult to estimate:
(external costs)
- reduction in the quality of life,
- damage to the environment.
- loss of arts and historic monuments.
|
The economic impact of the transport sector is usually
underestimated in terms of direct contribution to the
cross domestic product (approximately 3% in
Germany [1]).
However, the statistics above shows that an average German household
spends more money on transport and communication than on food which
account for 17% of all expenditures [4].
The reason for this difference is that the production of cars,
petrol and car-insurances are not directly produced in the transport
sector.
Other indirect costs are
- the part of the medical insurances that are dedicated to cure
injuries (1999: 521 thousand in Germany [4])
or other health problems caused by road traffic (like lung
diseases).
- costs caused by people who arrived too late plus secondary
costs if goods cannot be delivered because workers and components
have arrived late.
- buildings that got covered with a layer of soot or destroyed
by acid rain-falls need to be restored.
- inefficient use of transport infrastructure and vehicles:
infrastructure is not used at night, most vehicles are not used
during the greatest part of their life-time. Most streets are
built for trucks, but mostly used by cars.
External costs are all costs that are caused ``outside'' the
accounting of a particular transport system. Even though the
existence of these cost are evident it is often difficult to
determine the quantity of damage caused by traffic and the value of
these damages. For example:
- what is the value of the damaged gargoyle in Paris shown on the
picture ?
- how much would we pay if we could get stress-free to and from
work ? What are the alternatives ?
- How much would a city increase in value if there were parks
and playgrounds instead of streets and parking ?
- What are the costs of a damaged forest, a polluted sea and
air (including animals) ?
However, one can agree to prefer a transport system that is reducing
these costs compared with the present alternatives.
Can the problems be solved by introducing new technologies? How to
apply Information technologies (ITs), automation or electrical
engines to transportation systems?
- Evolution:
- These ``new'' technologies are applied to present
transportation systems. However, cars are not very suitable for
ITs, automatic control and electrical engines. The train on the
other side is not suitable to respond to today's mobility demand
and is in most cases not profitable.
- Revolution:
- A new transportation system is designed
that incorporates perfectly ITs, automatic control and electrical
engines and responds to today's mobility demand i.e. inherits the
flexibility of a car.
Any new transportation scheme that is going to supersede a
substantial proportion of the present transport systems must:
- have a high problem solving potential.
- be cheaper for users and profitable for operators and
manufacturers.
- be compatible with present transport infrastructure during a
transient phase.
|
`` science and technology
do not develop seamlessly, but rather by major and
painful changes in accepted wisdom
Such changes are preceded by a period of profound
uncertainty as the accepted solutions become plainly
unsatisfactory at solving the problems.''
Thomas Samuel Kuhn, Philosopher (1970)
|
Quotation from Thomas Kuhn: ``The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
'' [5].
The new paradigms are:
- driver-less, automatically guided, individual vehicles with a
size of a larger car.
- small, mass produced and therefore cheap electrical engines.
- small, light and inexpensive guideways.
- network with off-line stops and stations closer to origins and
destination of trips. This allows a lower capacity in each branch of
the network compared with a corridor oriented mass transit.